Which is better, the Audi A1 or Mercedes-Benz A-Class?

I’m retiring soon and wish to treat myself and buy a nearly-new petrol, manual car. Bearing in mind servicing cost, depreciation and resale - should I buy an Audi A1 Sportback or a Mercedes A180? Thanks.

Asked on 2 December 2020 by Chrisdogg

Answered by Andrew Brady

Both are good choices. It depends on your requirements, really. The Audi A1 is smaller and will be more suited to city driving, while the bigger A-Class will feel more suited to long motorway journeys. As a comfortable car for your retirement, we'd recommend the A-Class.

Tags: small cars

Similar questions

What small cars come with luxury features?

I require a small car with all of the luxury features one can find on larger cars. As far as I can see no manufacturer meets this requirement. Why not?

What used small automatic cars would you recommend?

I'm looking for a used (2017 -2022 ) good fuel economy car for short journeys but also good on motorways please. I need an automatic and have budget of up to £8000. My thoughts are Toyota Aygo, Kia Picanto...

What small cars have a high seating position?

I currently have a 2.0-litre Mazda MX5. I need car with high driving position (against headlight glare), but a small car that's fun and comfortable. What do you suggest?

Related models