Van & Pick-up MoT Test Results and Advice

MoT pass rates by make and model of van or pick-up

See the MoT pass rates for every make and model of van and pick-up.

The worst vans and pick-ups for passing the first MoT

Citroen Dispatch – 64.6% MoT pass rate

It doesn't matter which way you look at it, the MoT pass rate for the Dispatch van is poor. Delve into the numbers and three-year-old vans fail on a multitude of items, with suspension and electrical problems plaguing the Dispatch on MoT test day. As a result, its pass rate is 46 per cent worse than average for vans registered in 2014.

Click here to see the Citroen Dispatch’s MoT file

Citroen Relay – 66.6% MoT pass rate

Things don’t get much better for Citroen when it comes to the larger Relay van with its MoT file showing a lengthy list of issues.  One of the worst areas is the suspension, with front joints being five times more likely to fail the MoT than average for a three-year-old van. Body and structural items also perform badly, with a failure rate that is twice as high as the expected average.

Click here to see the Citroen Relay’s MoT file

Nissan NV200 – 68.4% MoT pass rate

The NV200 is the only Nissan to make it into this list, with lighting, tyres and driver’s view of the road being the problem areas. On average, the NV200 will perform 30 per cent worse than other 2014 vans at the first MoT, while headlamps have a failure rate that’s 120 per cent worse than average.   

Click here to see the Nissan NV200’s MoT file

Click here to see the vehicles with the lowest MoT pass rate

Toyota is the most reliable manufacturer for passing the first MoT

Toyota is the best manufacturer for passing the first MoT at three years, with eight out of 10 of its commercial vehicles obtaining a pass at the first attempt. More than 6000 Toyotas had an MoT in 2017, with fewer than 1200 failing.

Pick-up specialist Isuzu is second best with 80 per cent of its vehicles tested in 2017 obtaining a pass.

Mercedes-Benz is third, with a respectable pass rate of 70 per cent. The German firm is also the highest ranked large volume van maker in the MoT Files, with 23,000 vehicles having their first test in 2017 – more than both Toyota and Isuzu combined.

Citroen props up the table with a pass rate of almost 69 per cent. The French vanmaker has the lowest MoT score, while Renault is second worse with fewer than 72 per cent of vehicles passing. Nissan fares little better with some 72 per cent of vehicles passing. 

The Honest John Vans MoT Files is based on real world data from the DVSA - Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency. It shows that a quarter of a million vans had their first test in 2017, with 61,000 failing due to potentially dangerous defects. 

Manufacturer Tests Failures Pass rate
Toyota 6134 1191 80.6%
Isuzu 4410 867  80.3% 
Mercedes-Benz  23,364  4915  79.0% 
Mitsubishi  4985  1072  78.5% 
Volkswagen  34,549 7657  77.8% 
Ford  65,033  14495  77.7% 
Fiat  12,367  2847  77.0% 
Peugeot  26,687 6511  75.6% 
Iveco  2285  609 73.3% 
Vauxhall  24,593  6816  72.3% 
Nissan  8031  2237  72.1% 
Renault  14,771  4148  71.9% 
Citroen  22,954  7179  68.7% 

*Table is based on three-year-old vans and pick-ups having their first MoT test in 2017. List excludes manufacturers that had fewer than 2000 MoT tests in the calendar year. 

Top 10 vans and pick-ups for passing the MoT

Volkswagen Amarok – 84.2% MoT pass rate

The Amarok sails through its MoT test, with excellent pass rates for both tyre and brake wear. Suspension problems - a bugbear for many pick-ups, due to the weight they often carry - is also reassuringly low here, with a failure rate that’s lower than one per cent across all three-year-old Amaroks.

Click here to see the Volkswagen Amarok's MoT file

Ford Ranger – 81.0% MoT pass rate

It might be the UK’s best-selling pick-up, but the Ranger can’t match its German rival when it comes to the MoT. Pass rates are generally good, with tyre and brake wear being up to 50 per cent better than average. But suspension issues drag the overall score down with leaf spring wear being eight times worse than other 2014 pick-ups.

Click here to see the Ford Ranger's MoT file

Mercedes-Benz Vito – 79.1% MoT pass rate

The Vito is the best panel van for passing the first MoT with a respectable 79 per cent pass rate. Failures for lighting, electrical equipment and suspension are all notably lower than average, which means a typical owner can be rest assured that a three-year-old Vito will not empty their bank account on MoT test day.

Click here to see the Mercedes-Benz Vito's MoT file

Click here to see the 10 best vans and pick-ups for passing the first MoT

How much does the MoT cost? 

There’s a maximum amount MoT test stations can charge and this depends on the type of vehicle you drive.

Vehicle

Maximum MoT fee

Class 4 vehicles up to 3000kg design gross weight

£54.85

Class 4a vehicles with 9 to 12 passenger seats with a seat belt installation check

£64 

Goods vehicles over 3000kg up to 3500kg design gross weight

£58.60

When to book an MoT test

Vans are legally required to have an MoT test when they reach three years of age. The date for the first test is decided by the third anniversary of the vehicle’s registration, with a new MoT required every 12 months thereafter. You can find the date for the renewal of your vehicle's MoT pass certificate.

Check your car's MOT history

MoT failure categories

The DVSA introduced new defect categories for the MoT in 2018, with test faults being listed as Minor, Major or Dangerous.

Any van or pick-up that gets a Dangerous fault will automatically fail and be deemed illegal to be driven on the road. A Major fault will also result in a fail and be subject to a repair and retest. Minor defects are considered along the same lines as advisories, allowing the vehicle to pass with the faults being noted to the MoT history.

Category   What it means How it affects the MoT result
Dangerous  A direct and immediate risk to road safety or has a serious impact on the environment. You must not drive the vehicle until it’s been repaired.   Fail
Major

Defects may affect the vehicle’s safety, put other road users at risk and/or have an impact on the environment. Repair immediately.                

Fail

Minor

No significant effect on the safety of the vehicle or impact on the environment. Repair as soon as possible.         

Pass

Advisory

Potential defect could become more serious in the future. Monitor and repair if necessary.  

Pass
Pass

Meets the minimum legal standard. No future work deemed necessary.

Pass

 

What to do if your van fails the MoT

If your existing MoT is still valid and the van has a Major defect then you can theoretically drive the vehicle away from the MoT test centre. However, depending on the nature of the Major defect, you may be liable to prosecution if you are stopped by the police.

It is illegal to drive a vehicle away from the MoT station if the certificate has expired or a Dangerous defect has been detected. If this happens then you will need to have the vehicle repaired at the garage that carried out the MoT or arrange to have it trailered away.

You can be fined up to £2500 and be banned for driving a vehicle that has failed its MoT because of a Dangerous problem.

What happens if your MoT expires? 

If you have forgotten to renew your MoT then you should stop using the vehicle immediately. Only vans and pick-ups that are being driven to a garage for a pre-booked test can be used on the road without a valid MoT.

You can sign up for free MoT reminders with Honest John Homepages. By simply entering your van's registration number, we will keep an eye on when the MoT is due and when your VED is to be renewed. As well as keeping your van's history in one place, this is the home of your owner reviews, garage reviews, anything that you've asked through Ask Honest John and valuations.

Top 10 causes of van MoT failure in all vans 

Lamps, reflectors and electrical equipment - 653,352 failures

Over half of all van MoT failures are caused by some type of lighting problem.  More than 246,000 vehicles fail because the registration plate lamp is defective, while a further 154,000 are denied an MoT because of faulty brake lights. More than one in 10 vans will also fail because the headlight aim is dangerously adjusted.

Suspension – 406,488 failures

Given the packhorse nature of the modern van, it’s perhaps unsurprising to see so many fails due to suspension issues. However, while wear and tear to the springs, anti roll bars and suspension arms are to be expected, it’s worrying to see how many drivers are ignoring obvious problems. Does your van take you for a bumpy ride? It might be time to have it checked.

Brakes – 369,863 failures

A third of all vans will fail the MoT because the brakes are dangerously defective. Again, like suspension issues, this is often caused by the fact that vans carry heavy loads that can significantly increase wear and tear. And again, the tell-tale signs are usually easy to find, with a spongy pedal feel and/or vibrations being an indication that something is wrong.

Click here to see the top 10 causes of van MoT failure

Van MoT pass rates by year of registration

It’s no secret that the humble van lives a hard and difficult life. According to the latest MoT test data, the average van will have covered 47,000 miles by the time it has its first test at three years, while a car will have covered 26,000 miles over the same amount of time. As a result, just one in four vans pass the first MoT test at three years, compared to one in six cars.

By the time a van reaches five years, it'll have a 60 per cent chance of passing the MoT. This pass rate will continue to fall until the vehicle reaches 12 years of age, after this point the rate slows starts to climb as businesses scrap their worn out workhorses and enthusiasts start to put more money into their van to keep it on the road. 

Year of registration Number of MoT tests MoT pass rate
2014 250,318 75.5%
2013 211,629 70.2%
2012 185,082 65.6%
2011 194,924 62.4%
2010 170,422 60.5%
2009 142,389 58.5%
2008 198,901 55.5%
2007 214,904 53.5%
2006 199,225 51.3%
2005 176,401 50.1%
2004 160,449 48.7%
2003 125,584 47.9%
2002 84637 48.3%
2001 56,898 49.2%
2000 34,969 50.2%
1999 24,543 51.5%

MoT tests by postcode

As well as showing you pass rates by make and model, we can show you what the MoT pass rate is like in your local area. Does it make a difference? Yes, is the answer. We explain why and have a table of MoT pass rates by postcode here.


View MoT Data By Postcode in a larger map

 

Ask HJ

Why is my van cutting out after I had the head gasket changed?

I had the head gasket on my Peugeot Boxer changed, but on the way home (after about five miles) it decided to lose power and cut out. No lights came on the dashboard, it just went dead. After a couple of minutes it started and I got about 30 yards before it cut out again. Any idea what's wrong with it?
If it was done by a garage, we'd suggest that you get back to them to resolve it. If you did the job yourself, you should check for any coolant leaks, check for a spark at the plugs and make sure fuel is getting to the Injectors.
Answered by Alan Ross
More Questions
Ask HJ

Is it unwise to buy a van with a reconditioned engine?

I have seen a 2006 Renault Master, which has been converted to a horsebox. It also had a reconditioned engine in 2013. The mileage is 159,000 and the seller says the new engine has only 50,000 miles on it. People have said to avoid anything with a reconditioned engine. What do you advise?
Very much depends on what the seller means by 'reconditioned engine'. If the original engine was replaced with another unit from a different van then I would want to see some significant paperwork to show its history and mileage. Otherwise you have no proof that engine was new at all. For all you know, it could be older with far more mileage under its belt than the seller is letting on.
Answered by Dan Powell
More Questions
 

Ask Honest John

Value my van